In 1958, Route 322 was being widened to four lanes, so the hotdog stand had to relocate to the Harmonsburg Road for 18 months while Conneaut Lake Road was closed. When the road finally re-opened, Eddie bought the property where the business is currently located today. The founding Johnson's retired in 1988 when the couple turned over their secret sauce recipe and the keys to the roadside stand to their son and daughter-in-law, Eddie and Jose' Johnson, who had been working there for more than 20 years. In 1991, Eddie and Jose decided to make a switch and start purchasing their footlong hotdogs from a local favorite, Smith's Provision from Erie, PA. They are also a family owned and operated business that takes pride in quality products. The switch proved to be a good one. In 2001, Eddie's Footlong celebrated selling their 1,000,000 Smith's brand footlong hotdog. How many footlongs were sold in the years prior to the switch is just a guess.